Maui

This property is frequently mentioned as the prime luxury option in Wailea, offering a vibrant, 'non-sleepy' atmosphere. However, opinions are mixed on its rooms, with some finding them basic and not recently updated despite renovations. Service is generally well-regarded, but issues like chaise lounge availability being first-come, first-served at 6 am are noted.

Honest negative: Rooms are described as looking the same after a renovation, with comments suggesting they are 'very basic FS rooms' and appear 'old'.

Highly recommended for couples and anniversary trips, Sensei is praised for its secluded, romantic, and adult-only atmosphere. It's seen as a more special, less overtly developed option compared to Maui's larger resorts, offering unique experiences like private hale time.

Honest negative: Drawbacks are tied to its exclusivity; it's an adults-only property, making it unsuitable for families and a choice that can only be experienced before having children.

This resort is lauded for its secluded and romantic vibe, offering a stark contrast to the more developed areas of Maui. It's considered an ideal choice for a relaxing vacation, with included flights from Oahu on Lanai Air.

Honest negative: The primary negative is the logistical complexity and potential time loss involved in travelling between Lanai and other islands, which can take up a significant portion of a short trip.

Mentioned as a potentially charming option, particularly for its boutique feel. However, some guests find it not to be on the beach and question its value at a five-star price point, especially when compared to beachfront properties.

Honest negative: It's not on the beach, and some feel it's in the same building zone as mid-range housing subdivisions, detracting from the expected luxury location.

This property is noted for its family-friendly amenities, including multiple water slides and lazy rivers, making it a strong contender for family vacations. Rooms are considered nice enough, though not at the Four Seasons level. It's also mentioned as a place where Jeff Goldblum has been spotted multiple times.

Honest negative: Rooms are described as 'fine, not to the level of a 4S', and it's noted to have 'too many kids' for some travellers seeking a more tranquil experience.

This property received a disappointing review, with villas described as dated and restaurants not meeting expectations.

Honest negative: The villas were described as 'dated' and the restaurants 'weren’t that great'.

Generally positive feedback, with suites and villas being highlighted. However, service was noted as being 'almost non-existent' post-Covid.

Honest negative: Service was described as 'almost non-existent' during a post-Covid stay.

Praised for large 2 or 3-bedroom suites and an adults-only pool by the beach walk. It's noted as being a short walk to the Four Seasons for spa and restaurant access.

Honest negative: While convenient for FS access, the review suggests not recommending other hotels in the area due to too many kids and mediocre service/restaurants.

Mentioned in comparison to other Hawaiian properties, with one user considering it for the future but noting service reviews needed more time to mature.

Honest negative: One user noted that they decided against it due to 'service reviews' and felt it 'needed more time to work on service'.

Seen as a more budget-friendly option compared to Maui, offering a spectacular adults' pool and good value for money despite being in a high-rise with 'Marriott bones'.

Honest negative: There is no good bar on-site, and cocktail prices are considered high, with an Espresso Martini costing $35.

Praised for its club level product, which is considered to stand apart due to its integration of space, design, service, and added inclusions like activities and insider access, rather than just lounge access.

Honest negative: While the club offering is strong, it's noted that the 'hard product of rooms is certainly nicer elsewhere' as it's built on 'Marriott bones'.

Described as 'fantastic' by one user.